Israel - Passport Stamp.

I'm travelling to Israel on Christian pilgrimage in a few weeks. I've been to Israel twice (2012 and 2015), however in 2012 I got a stamp on my passport but in 2015 I got an immigration clearance paper instead.

I want to find out if I can ask them for a stamp on my passport instead of the paper? I love seeing those Israeli stamps on my passport(s).

Has anyone got an Israeli stamp on their passports in recent years or months, please???